Open Letter to Oklahoma Voters and Lawmakers


I am a teacher. I teach English at the high school of an independent district within Oklahoma City. I love my job. I love your kids. I call them my kids. I keep blankets in my room for when they’re cold. I feed them peanut butter crackers, beef jerky, or Pop Tarts when Michelle Obama’s school breakfast or lunch isn’t enough to fill their bellies. I comfort them when they cry and I praise them when they do well and always I try to make them believe that they are somebody with unlimited potential no matter what they go home to when they leave me.

What do they go home to? Sometimes when they get sick at school they can’t go home because you and the person you’re currently shacking up with are too stoned to figure out it’s your phone ringing. Sometimes they go home to parents who don’t notice them, and those are often the lucky kids. Sometimes they go home to sleep on the neighbor’s back porch because your boyfriend kicked them out of the house and his dog is too mean to let them sleep on their own back porch. They go home to physical and verbal abuse. They go home looking for love and acceptance from the people who created them … and too often they don’t find it.

Many days your children bring the resentment they feel toward you to school with them and they act out against peers, property, or their teachers. When I call you I’m told, “When he’s at school he’s your problem.” Or you beat them, not for what they did, but because it embarrassed or inconvenienced you when I called.

Often, they stay at school with me for an hour and a half after the bell rings because they don’t want to go home to you. Reluctantly, they get on the two buses meant to take home students who stay for athletic practice, and they go away for a dark night in places I can’t imagine.

Over 90 percent of the kids in my high school are on the free or reduced lunch programs. The walk hand-in-hand with Poverty and its brother Violence. They find comfort in the arms of your lover, Addiction. They make babies before they are old enough to vote. Or drive. And they continue the cycle you put them in.

Sometimes I get through to a student and convince her that education is the way out of this spiral of poverty and despair. Then you slap them down for wanting to be better than you.

And you, the lawmakers of this state, you encourage it. I hold two college degrees and have been on my job for 10 years. I was our school’s Teacher of the Year in 2014. I teach kids to read the ballots that keep you in your elite position. I teach them to look behind your lies and rhetoric. I teach them to think for  themselves. The compensation of me and my colleagues ranks 49th in the nation, and is the lowest in our region. I currently earn about $18,000 per year less than I did in 2002, my last year as an office worker for an energy company that merged with another and eliminated my job. I feel like my life has purpose now, but, as I turn 50 this year and wonder how I’ll put my own high school-age kids through college, I have to consider giving up helping scores of kids per year so I can afford to give my own children what they need to find satisfaction in their lives.

And what do you do? You whittle away at education funding. You waste the taxpayers’ money so that our great state faces unbelievable shortfalls and massive budget cuts. You take home a salary that ranks 10th highest in the nation among state legislators and you are inept, uncaring, and an abomination to our democratic form of government.

Those kids who stay after school with me? After Spring Break 2016 they can’t do that. You see, our district can no longer afford to pay to run those late buses. Your kids wade through garbage in the halls because we had to release the custodial crew that cleaned at night. Oh sure, we could make the kids clean up after themselves, except our administrators live in fear of lawsuits, and making a kid pick up the lunch tray he threw on the floor has been considered forced child labor. There’s also the very real possibility that a belligerent kid will just take a swing at one of us — again — because he or she wasn’t taught respect for authority at home. Did I mention how we had to let go of our security officers because we could no longer afford them? We now share one single solitary Oklahoma County Sheriff’s deputy with our ninth grade center and our middle school and alternative school. That’s one deputy for about 1,300 students.

We can no longer afford rolls of colored paper or paint or tape to make signs to support and advertise our Student Council activities. This fall our football team won’t charge through a decorated banner as they take the field because we can’t afford to make the banner. There won’t be any new textbooks in the foreseeable future. Broken desks won’t be replaced. We’re about to ration copy paper and we’ve already had the desktop printers taken out of our rooms.

We live in fear that our colleagues will leave us, not just because they are our friends, but because the district wouldn’t replace them even if we could lure new teachers to our inner-city schools during the teacher shortage you have caused. We fear our classes doubling in size.

We fear becoming as ineffective as you are. Not because we can’t or won’t do our job, like you, but because you keep passing mandates to make us better while taking away all the resources we need just to maintain the status quo. We fear that our second jobs will prevent us from grading the papers or creating the lesson plans we already have to do from home. We fear our families will leave us because we don’t have time for them.

I am the chairman of my department. My teachers could easily take other jobs in the private sector where they would make more money, but so far they have chosen to remain teachers because they love working with kids. How long will they continue to put the needs of students over the needs of family? It’s something we’re all dealing with. How far will you push us? What will you do without us when we leave the classroom or leave the state? It’s happening. You know it’s happening, and yet you do nothing.

You, the representatives, senators, and governor of Oklahoma are creating a population of ignorant peasants fit only to work in the oil field and factories you bring to this state by promising those businesses won’t have to pay their fair share of taxes. You leave our kids in a cycle of poverty and abuse while your pet donor oil companies destroy the bedrock beneath us, shaking our homes to pieces while you deny your part in all of it.

Parents, I beg you to love your children the way we love your children. Vote for people who will help teachers educate and nurture the kids we share. We can’t do it alone anymore.

795 responses to “Open Letter to Oklahoma Voters and Lawmakers”

  1. Thank you for your heart and sharing. I pray something will be done about this mess!

  2. Reblogged this on sherriesblurbandblunders and commented:
    This teacher nails it all on the head, and these problems are not just out west in Oklahoma they are every where

  3. I would not want my children anywhere near you. Pointing fingers and placing blame is not a solution to fixing anything. Slandering our First Lady and our President shows ultimate disrespect for our country’s leaders.
    Blaming parents and pretending you “actually” know what really is going on in their homes when you are not there…. I’m sure you’ve heard the old teachers saying, “don’t believe everything my kid tells you about me and I won’t believe everything my kid tells me about you”.
    You knew what the job paid when you took it. Be thankful, be grateful and stop playing the martyr.

    1. Oh, Lorna. It’s clear you’ve never been a public school teacher. Because it doesn’t matter WHERE his job is, the concerns apply to schools across the country. When a child comes to you upset, wearing the same clothes multiple days in a row, with bags under their teary eyes…I’m not “pretending” to know what is going on in their home. I KNOW something is going on in their home.

      1. joshua twoaxes Avatar
        joshua twoaxes

        At the State level,
        the National School Lunch Program is usually administered by State education agencies, which operate the program through agreements with school food authorities.(http://www.fns.usda.gov/sites/default/files/NSLPFactSheet.pdf). So, this is direct from the national lunch program’s website, please stop blaming the first lady for the ineptitude of your particular State. Yes, i did have the misfortune of living in Tulsa for a year, and OK is that poor of a place to live. So, either keep on trucking, or move. Very simple, but don’t blame the government for the shortfalls of your State. To make matters worse, your State just decided to kick over a hundred thousand poor people off of Medicaid to balance the budget(nevermind the tax breaks that could have gone to education but instead went to the frackers that are causing your earthquakes), so you will continue to see those sick kids for the immediate future. Good luck with that…

        1. This is not just a problem in Oklahoma and if you think that, then you are part of the problem.

    2. This comment is best read with ‘Dueling Banjos’ playing in the background.

    3. Lorna,

      I see what you are trying to say in that you don’t want people to point fingers or place blame. I grew up in Oregon in a difficult home. My mom, whom I love dearly, was a gamboling addict, and her poor choices resulted in awful relationships and eventually her abuse, and the abuse of myself and my siblings. It also resulted in the lights being turned off, the water being turned off, and our cupboards being empty. Fortunately, I had teachers, school counselors and other family who noticed what was happening and they reached out. They empowered me. They cared for me. They fed me. They gave me hope.

      By the grace of God, I worked my way through college, graduated, and got an amazing job at Microsoft. Of my mother, siblings and myself, I am the first one to have made it out of the cycle of poverty. I think this issue goes beyond whether the school has paper for banners and it brings up an important question – what will those in need do when those who empower them (teachers) have to leave the school district and leave the state in order to support their own families?

      When legislators control the budget, we should absolutely let the blame rest on them for the lack of funding. They have the power to make choices, and they don’t choose to fund education or safe spaces for these kids. Are they bad people? No. Are they uninformed and unaware of the cycle of poverty? Probably. Does the weight of education and the future of many lives rest on their shoulders? Yes, it absolutely does. And because of that, they should take a good, long look at the choices they are making and who they are impacting.

      I’m sure that you, too, are a wonderful person, Lorna. I don’t doubt that you are kind and fearless and a fierce protector of your kids. So, I have no problem with asking you to reconsider your position, because there are entire families out there that are neglecting their children. There are families who are so caught up in the cycle of poverty and addiction that they cannot and do not care for their children the way you might care for yours. You say teachers “pretend” to know what is happening in the homes of their students. I say that teachers wish they could pretend that they DON’T know what’s going on in the homes of their students. You may be safe and your children may be safe in your home, but the unfortunate reality is that there are a lot of students in the depths of poverty, abuse and addiction. The more families we have pretending that there isn’t a problem, the more children will fall to the wayside.

      As a survivor of the cycle of poverty, I stand by this teacher, because he is giving his honest account about problems that you might never encounter in your life. If I were to advise you in any way, I would suggest that you go volunteer with City Impact in the Tenderloin District of San Francisco, or a similar organization in the inner-city. There you will see how the cycle of poverty has gripped this nation. You will meet bright, young students with big hearts who are relatively untainted by the world, and you will watch as they walk home to a one-bedroom apartment that they share with 5 people, or walk down the street past drug deals, or duck when they hear shots fired. Please, go take a close look, because it is ignorance and the “we don’t really know” lie that will be the blunt sword that pierces this nation, the results of which will surely be continued gentrification and the complete extinction of the American Dream.

      Best,
      Elayne

      1. Elayne,
        What an impassioned, insightful, honest, and graceful response. Thank you.
        Brooks

      2. Elayne, that is a beautiful, compassionate response. Thank you! I’m so happy you were able to escape and find success and happiness. You’re definitely right about wishing we didn’t know certain things. Just today one of my kids gave me a note apologizing for not doing her best in my class. Her mom kicked her out two weeks ago. The girl is 16. Mom kicked her out because Mom’s new boyfriend didn’t want the kid there. If I didn’t know these things I could lecture for my six periods, then come home and sit in front of the TV like everyone else. Thank you again for your comment!

        1. so, have you reported what you know to the authorities?? If not why not? If you did what action did the authorities take?

          In many states NOT reporting suspected child abuse is a CRIME.

          1. Carol Roessing Avatar
            Carol Roessing

            During my 30 year career of teaching in elementary schools, I’ve witnessed suspected abuse situations. In one case where the teacher suspected sexual abuse of her first grader based on comments the little girl made and the fact that she was having frequent vaginal infections, the teacher reported it, which resulted in a visit to the child’s doctor, who insisted it wasn’t the result of sexual abuse so the case didn’t go any further. (The mother was working full time, boyfriend remained in the house.) In another case, a first grader (again,) was referred to social services based on suspected sexual abuse. The mother worked full time; step-father did not. It was taken to court; the judge ruled that the child could return home so long as she was not left alone with the step-father. Now you tell me who was going to be monitoring this scenario 24/7? So is the problem solved by reporting the abuse? No!

          2. I hope these are rhetorical questions considering there can be dire consequences to ever admitting to calling authorities. A teacher at my school called authorities and when the authorities stated that a teacher from our school contacted them in their report, the person threatened to come into our school and shoot and kill all of us. The way the person found out who called was the local radio station broadcasted this in their “news” hour and local newspaper published the report. Where’s the anonymity in calling? Where’s the protection? We were sent an 88 year old security guard (I asked him) to be posted at our school. We feared for his health and safety and all decided we’ll have to protect him too when the shooter comes.

            The police came to our school and flat out said that if a shooter comes we better keep him busy for 3 minutes because that is their minimum response time to our school. The teachers practice regularly what to do for those 3 minutes. This doesn’t sound like a long time but when you’re living it, it feels like a lifetime. We even had a police team come in and the officer had an air gun and pretended to roam our school shooting us and helping us learn what to do for those 3 minutes. Even though I knew it was an air gun, having that aimed point-blank between my eyes was still terrifying and when he pulled the trigger I still jumped and cried that night from the stress.

            Educators know that, “NOT reporting suspected child abuse is a CRIME” and we do it even if there is a chance that we are putting not just our life in danger but others as well.

            Don’t judge until you’ve walked a mile in the other person’s shoes.

    4. We know more about what goes on inside your house than you do. Maybe your take the abuse and be grateful attitude is even more telling then your stay out of my business, my kid is a liar stance. Just know, we don’t judge parents, we are here for another resource for the kids. When a kid sees abuse, violence or inability to pay for basic goods, we don’t blame parents, we only try to convince them the mistakes their parents made, don’t have to be theirs. By the way, this week I have not gotten a single planning period, I stayed until 7pm twice and I just spent about 6 mins of my 30 mins for the entire day to myself (oh this included that lunches that I volunteer to tutor students that aren’t even mine to prevent from failing) to respond to you. That’s how utterly misinformed you are.

    5. Wow, you are incredible, clearly you are not a teacher. Our countrys leaders have become a joke, or have you not been watching the Donald Trump Show?????

      How much do you make? Teachers are the lowest paid and mostly highly educated professionals in our country. Perhaps it is about time people start talking about what is REALLY going on in our schools. Teachers take all the blame. When we are NOT the problem. This guy nailed it on the head. You should want your kids around someone like this. Shame on you.

      1. Do YOUR job Stevev Wadel. You are not a social worker, therapist or after school sitter. You are bound by law to report child abuse/neglect. Stop trying to play super hero and pay attention to your own kids. You just want to pretend you are above every one. And think you can sit in judgement of others. You are just a winer, a cry baby and a hypocrite. AGAIN, I THANK GOD you are no where near my children. Stop writing letters, that you suck at, and get a second job. You chose to be a teacher, quit bitching about it.

        1. Thank you for the free entertainment Lorna. I have gotten a great laugh out of your clearly uninformed comments to a topic which you clearly know absolutely nothing about. But for you own dignity, you may want to stop posting. The things you are saying just keep getting more blatantly misinformed and ignorant.

          Citizens like you are the reason education is failing. Educators like this man are going to be the ones to save the future of education so YOUR children and grandchildren can grow up in a thriving country. You are welcome.

    6. When it becomes “ultimate disrespect” to criticize our country’s leaders, we may be ready for Ultimate Law to prohibit any such criticism. Such Ultimate Law was very effective in Hitler’s Germany, for example, where children reported parents for making fun of the Fuhrer’s nose, leading to a prompt visit by the Gestapo.

    7. Lorna Fry, you are one of the problems, not the solution, to the issues this and every other teacher in the nation is having. Michele Obama should be in these classrooms to see the effect her lunch choices have on these children. I’m SURE she doesn’t eat this way. So, to bring an issue to the public’s notice, not that the public isn’t already aware, is now “pointing fingers and placing blame?” So, in your little diatribe, where’s YOUR solution? Other than pointing fingers and placing blame? Are you “offended” by this article? Too bad. Grow up and find a solution or keep your unsolicited negativity to yourself.

      1. Bashing other people is your great solution? Hurting people hurt people. I will pray for you. I forgive you for being a hater. I don’t know what pain you are dealing with, but you will dwell in it until you replace hate with love. God Bless You.

        1. ‘You just want to pretend you are above every one. And think you can sit in judgement of others. You are just a winer, a cry baby and a hypocrite.’

          Lorna, did you forget you wrote this? I copied and pasted your direct quote. You are the only one calling names. I’d say I will pray for you, but unlike you, I don’t use that term to make myself feel better about disrespecting others.

    8. You clearly have never been a teacher. Yes we DO know what goes on in the home. Not only do we talk to our students, we visit homes and get to know families as well. Oh, and we also talk to the children’s social workers/doctors/psychologists, and get notified of the Hotline calls made to child services, and answer questions from child services/doctors/police when we are contacted, just to mention a few things we do (‘off the clock’ by the way). So yes, I think we get a pretty accurate picture of what goes on in a student’s life.

      I’m also not sure what post you read, but the one I read did not slander the First Lady, and did it even mention the president? He simply said many students come to school extremely hungry–so WE feed them.

      He is thankful and grateful for his job–he says repeatedly how much he loves it. What he is worried about is that he needs to make a LIVEABLE WAGE (not having to work 2 and 3 jobs as most of us do) in order to care for his own family. We also need resources, materials, functioning buildings, and many other basic things to be able to teach. In what other profession (not that you probably think it is a ‘profession’, but yes we are highly educated, certified, individuals with much experience in our field of expertise) are workers expected to donate hundreds to thousands of dollars of their own money to the workplace in order to do their job? Not one.

      Walk a week in a teacher’s shoes (especially a Title 1 teacher’s shoes–assuming you even know enough about the education world to know what that is). I challenge you. You would immediately regret this post you made.

      The person I would not want my children around is someone like you—the person who clearly knows nothing about the situation, but feels the need to comment on it and bash a complete stranger. The only person ‘slandering’ here seems to be you.

      Amen to him for having the courage to stand up to policy makers when so many of us feel too scared for our jobs to say anything. You’d be lucky to have someone like him fighting to get your child what he/she deserves.

      1. I would never rely on the likes of you and him to “help” my children. You are both judgemental and sooo egotistical! Behold!!! Our Saviors!!!! I will pray for God to change your hateful and judgemental hearts. It’s sad what you are teaching these poor innocent children.

        1. You are right. We are disgusting, hideous, self-centered people. It’s probably something all teachers have in common. You should probably not have any contact with any of us ever again. And please leave us out of your prayers. Thank you–we sincerely appreciate it.

  4. Reblogged this on Praying for Eyebrowz and commented:
    Important words here. Scary words. Truthful words. Read more at stevenewedel.wordpress.com.

  5. Thank you for all you do for the children in your school district! I must say I have never read such a moving blog before. Teachers need a voice and the government seems to be the one putting the tape over our teachers mouths. It’s not right and thank you for pulling the tape off and speaking out! I loved your blog and how you called out the “bad” parents and our government who doesn’t care, because as long as they get their huge paycheck they could care less about our children or school systems! The only thing I didn’t see in your blog that I would have like to see along with the rest is giving credit to the good parents that are out there because we care about our kids, schools, and the teachers. God bless you sir and keep fighting the good fight!

    1. Did we miss something? Teachers are disenfranchised?
      What of the teachers union? What of the right to vote? What of the right to contact public officials. What of the Right of Petition? What of the right to put issues on a ballot? What of the right to Recall public officials? What of the right of Referendum?

      Seems that before teachers throw up their hands, whine, and blame others for a situation they disagree with, they should first exercise their rights. They just might find the public doesn’t agree or they might find it does.

      1. Not all teachers are able to participate in a union. When my husband worked as a charter school teacher in CO the contract stated that teachers were forbidden to create or join a union or any other group that acted like a union. OK is a right to work state just like CO is and employees can be let go for no reason at all. It is the same with teachers. Before you start to say that teachers need to exercise their rights you must understand more about how teachers are treated by a vast number of administrators. They fear for their jobs when they aren’t protected in right to work states.

        1. And what of all the other rights I mentioned? Recall, Referendum, Petition, Voting?

      2. Teacher unions are banned under Georgia law.

      3. Last week I took a class on negotiation from a federal labor negotiator who was clear about one thing: teacher unions in the south are very weak! Only in northern states like Illinois or New York are they significantly more influential. Yet so many in the south have swallowed the propaganda that the teachers unions are always powerful. This is simply not true.

        1. joshua twoaxes Avatar
          joshua twoaxes

          They swallowed the Party propaganda that teacher’s are making out like bandits ad need to be reined in, this is why they have no power. Again, don’t like the policies, then move…

      4. Teachers unions have little or no power anymore, clearly you have not been watching Wisconsin get rid of their union. over 50% of the states do not have a teachers union.

        When was the last time, you saw any citizen in this country be able to get anything accomplished. Our government has ben hijacked by the likes of Donald Trump and Croportate America.

      5. Please do your research before you comment bashing people you know nothing about. Many states do not have teachers unions.

  6. Derek Edwards Avatar

    And make sure the money goes to active teachers. I’m in Michigan, where administration and retirees get first dibs.

  7. Amen Mr. Wedel!!!! I look at the negative comment above and wonder “what is this woman thinking”….. I can tell you one thing… she isn’t thinking of others or the betterment of our children & grandchildren. I think it is very sad that the assumption is made that they all are being dishonest about any type of abuse or mistreatment at home. As a staff member in a public school system, no matter what position, we are morally responsible to take action if we even suspect abuse or neglect in a home of a student. The current state of education rests solely on our capital, the governor & our representatives! If you don’t agree, please tell me who it DOES rest on?? As parents and teachers, action must be taken immediately! I am in fear for my own child’s future & my job!!

  8. If hand wringing and good intentions created a Utopia, we’d being living in one right now.
    Honestly many of you folks, who are teachers and perhaps have advanced degrees amaze me.
    Your constant montra is more money. The fact is the USA spends more per capita than any other country for education.
    The fact is our students DO NOT fair well against those of other countries.
    The fact is the teacher’s union is an arm of the Democratic party
    The fact is teachers can teach and kids can learn, but NOT in the environment that has been foisted upon them by those who burden schools with being daycare centers and social service delivery systems
    The fact is there is zero to little discipline in the schools because certain students who attend have no business being there

    1. Mr. Breen, those other countries to which you refer only allow their top 10-15% g to high school. If you only measure our top 15%, we blow them out of the water. But here, he allow every child to have the “same” opportunity One size fits all. And your last two points are part of what Mr. Wedel is talking about.

      1. Please show you source for, “only 15%” In Japan for example every student is on the same page of the same book every day and its not just the top 15%

        Regardless, there is much to be said for not every child goes to the same type of secondary education. Academics is not for everyone (thankfully) as if it were we’d have all college grads, many with no actual skill set. More importantly there would be no electricians, auto mechanics, plumbers, construction workers, etc.

    2. Carol Roessing Avatar

      I don’ t know what the percentage is, but Mr. Cummings is correct when he says that other countries only send the cream of the crop to their secondary schools. How can you accurately compare apples with oranges?
      Concerning spending per capita: during 30 years of teaching, I have taught in both city and suburban schools. Those schools whose results were the best were those with the most money (via higher property taxes in suburbs vs. lower in city systems). However, the other major factor regarding quality learning is the role of the family unit. Those parents who were interested and supportive of their child’s education, spent time with their children, participated in the school activities, helped with homework, etc. were the ones whose children improved and excelled. Those students from drug-related, indifferent, hungry, or otherwise dysfunctional families had difficulty learning, which brings me to the daycare and social service systems you complain about. If the schools didn’t provide this assistance, things would be worse. The bottom line is, it all takes sufficient funds.

    3. joshua twoaxes Avatar
      joshua twoaxes

      We do not spend the most per capita, we are about in the middle, globally…

    4. Fact: In most countries they do not test EVERY student like we do in the US. If you camparatively test our students with the sames students in China, Europe, etc. Actually America would fare in the top 5. If you tested EVERY kid in China they would score at the bottom. Those facts are scewed.
      More money, how much do you make? Teachers have a starting salary in the low $30,000. Less and less people are going into education all the time because they cannot afford to considering what college costs.
      YOu are absolutely right, schoolare are a daycare, and social service delivery systems. Unfortunately you cannot teach children who suffer from abuse, and neglect, and who are hungry, homeless, or scared. My class size is 38. Have you every tried to manage 38 students at one time? Not easy.
      It will take money, and honestly I don’t know where the money goes, but it is not in the salary of teachers, or into classroom supplies, etc. That is for sure.

  9. It seems to me a lot of Americans are becoming disillusioned and embittered with their life, irresponsible with their family. And this is leading parts of society to become a bunch of drug addicts and waste-products. This to me is marking the decline of the US. What a shame. I still fail to understand how can part of society be in such an appalling state and yet the US is continuing to lead the world in science and technology????

  10. Beautifully written. And so sad. It’s tough in education all over the country right now. Thanks for bringing such heartache to our leaders’ attention.

  11. Thank you very much for sharing the plight of a teacher and for highlighting many of the issues that our school children face. My husband has also been a teacher for 7 years and has witnessed many of the same issues and travesties that you have listed here. For those who think that this is anything short of accurate, they should spend one year teaching and then share their opinions. It is easy to play arm chair quarterback but until you are actually on the field, you don’t truly know what you are talking about. Please keep up the good fight. Our country’s children need you.

  12. Thank you for your words. Teachers WILL leave Oklahoma. I left 20 years ago because despite my master’s degree and experience, I could not support my family on a single income in the field of education in Oklahoma. It’s sad to know things are pretty much still the same. I have been a committed educator now for 30 years, in another state. The college education I received in Oklahoma has been used on students in another state. I hope someone there wakes up before there is mass exodus of quality and experienced teachers.

    1. joshua twoaxes Avatar
      joshua twoaxes

      They should leave, free market system, right?

    2. I Am Grateful Avatar

      We will be better off when you do leave and get teachers in there who are actually grateful to have a job. Good riddance!

  13. I retired in June of 2015 after 40 years as a teacher in Philadelphia, PA. I worked exclusively with children from the poorest sections of the city. Everything Mr. Wedel says is true about the conditions of schools all over the U.S. I had to buy my own computer printer and ink for it and for the previous school printer I had. I bought food for my students even after the Philadelphia School District told us that we would not be able to count food purchases towards the measly $100 per year teacher allotment. I was spending $100 per month buying prizes for my Special Education students for work and behavior, food, pencils, pens, crayons, color markers, fee-for-use internet web sites for my classes, and other expenses that were critical for my students’ education and personal needs. However, Mrs. Obama should not be blamed for anything, as each school district supervises its own food programs. Her ideas were not carried out by any district I know of other than those that cared about student nutrition and could also afford to pay for high quality food. My students ate the cheapest, most fattening junk that the food service company could provide and still make a huge profit for the per-meal cost they got for each student. Many students refused to eat the crap they were served. They were extremely hungry during class time, so I needed to feed them so they could concentrate on learning rather than their empty stomachs. In Pennsylvania, our previous Republican governor gave massive tax breaks to businesses and wealthy individuals and REFUSED to tax the new fracking industry in our state. The Republican-held state legislature has consistently cut millions from public schools while giving more money to charter and private religious schools (which I thought was illegal under the Constitution). Comments made in Philadelphia news websites about teachers were vastly more negative than positive. Go on Facebook and join The BAT group of teachers to see national reports about how every state is purposely ruining public education so charter schools can take over. If you think that’s not true, look at the pro-charter groups funded by the likes of billionaires like Bill Gates and Eli Broad. They are poised to give a tremendous push throughout the country to make public education look so bad that people will demand a change to private control of education. We must actively work to change the political views of our state and federal legislatures or suffer the consequences of our inertia and political inactivity.

    1. Please, stop with the failed agenda you espouse.
      Public education is what it is, not very good. Catholic schools do much better with less and have since their inception. Public schools are a creation of and managed by the government
      Net result is and will always be a wasteful, inept system run and populated by officials who are there virtually for life.
      Aside from perhaps the military, there is not a single efficiently or effectively operated government system and never will be.
      Privatization is not perfect, but in many if not most situations it is more effective and less costly. It doesn’t require the administrative overkill found in public schools.

      1. Catholic schools get to pick their pupils and reject others. So can other private/Christian schools. Can public schools do that? No. Private schools often do not provide special education programs for children with disabilities. (Thankfully some Catholic schools do provide mild/moderate programs with students on an IEPs, but do not provide programs for severely disabled kids.) What are you going to do with that population of students? Leave them on the street? That’s UNAMERICAN! Compulsory education was passed by Massachusetts in 1852 in the longstanding tradition of the Puritans that parents should be required to educate their children, a tradition that goes back into the 1640s when the Puritans were first arriving in America. England and Wales were among the LAST countries of Europe to require compulsory education (Didn’t happen until 1870). After the Mejji Restoration in Japan, that country sent officials to study and adopt the AMERICAN system of public education so they could implement it at home. The Japanese copied us….not Britain, France, Germany, or any other country. You may think PUBLIC education is an evil, and inefficient. But I think its necessary because private schools won’t cover everyone. I believe you have the right to choose any way you want to educate your kids: private, home school, or public. But I don’t think you deserve a tax credit or voucher just because you choose to use one of the first two options. If you feel you need to use those options you should find a way to afford it.

        1. You’re dead wrong about Catholic schools. Have direct Board experience. Also many have funds to help the kids who can’t afford the tuition.

          You won’t agree, but my 70 years on this earth in several different states indicates that kids who are raised in the Judeo-Christian and other religious tradition coupled to American traditions and values are better prepared to be educated.

          Please don’t try to compare today’s education system with that of even 20 years ago.

          Public schools are not working precisely because the model that once existed is no more. It’s been replaced by the glorification of sports, social engineering, and daycare services.

      2. Carol Roessing Avatar

        Please stop with your erroneous assumptions!
        You say “public education is not very good”. There are too many variable factors to consider to make that statement, such as financing, socioeconomic, parental support, family cohesiveness,etc. Granted, one school public school system may be better than another. My grandchildren are receiving an excellent public education. Why? They live in a suburb that has everything: affluent families, beautiful public parks, highly functonal family units, parents that are well educated, care about their children’s educations and participate in their activites. The schools provide all kinds of extra curricular and service programs. they attract highly qualified teachers because of the amenities,good teaching conditions, and good salaries. Many community programs are available here, also. Why is all this possible? Money, money, money! Property taxes are extremely high here, with lots of affluent neighborhoods thus providing sufficient funds.

        Now, let’s look at an inner city school. No affluence, dysfunctional families, poverty, hungry children. Property taxes do not cover expenses of even rundown schools. What a contrast! I’ve taught in both types of schools. I know, I’ve seen the difference. I’ve seen teachers knock themselves out to make only small inroads.

        Let’s talk about privatization. I agree that it is not perfect. I have friends who taught in catholic schools and I’m not sure that you are right that it is less expensive. Parents pay tuition, our public schools provide busing for the catholic schools, as well as special education services. Catholics do penalize their teachers by paying them far less than public school teachers. Have you ever noticed that the majority of private school teachers are married women.? That’s because a single teacher could not support a family on what they earn.
        Let’s talk about quality…Catherine is right about Catholic schools not having to accept all students. One of our students with a severe discipline problem was pulled from our school…the parents were in denial, blamed the teachers for his problems. They enrolled him in our local Catholic school. Within 6 months he was back because the Catholic school refused to deal with him. So now do you know why the Catholic schools may do better with less money? Not exactly admirable.

        What about charter schools? I know a teacher who taught in one briefly. There was no curriculum, very little in the way of supplies, books, etc. Consequently, she spent a lot of her own money on materials. There was no continuity in what was taught at any grade level. Each teacher had to come up with her own curriculum. She was paid so little that she had to live at home with her parents and commute from northern Ohio to Columbus every day. Charter schools do not have to comply with state mandates as public schools do and yet we taxpayers are paying for those vouchers from state money. Currently, some.of our charter schools are being investigated for mishandling funds. After comparing test results from Charter schools with public schools, it has been determined that they are not reaching acceptable educational goals.

        It appears to me, from his comments, that Mr. Breen has not had enough first hand knowledge or experience within the public education system to be able to draw logical conclusions about it. Since only the wealthy can afford to send their children to private schools, I wonder what he suggests we do about educating all others if we didn’t have public schools.

        1. Some Solutions

          1. Keep the Federal Government out
          2. Reduce the number of administrators
          3. Take all unions out of the school systems
          4. create a dual track curriculum – academic and vocational
          5. Have a strict policy on unruly students
          6. mandate that a teacher report all suspected child abuse to legal authority
          7. Remove all illegal aliens
          8. Put all teachers on a merit system
          9. Put all teachers on contracts limited to two years @ a time
          10. Reduce sports funding
          11. Prohibit graduating a student from high school who is unable to function @ an 8th grade level
          12. Prohibit day care services and special after hours bus service except to those who are in a qualified school program

          1. You are showing your conservative bias and ignorance again Mr. Breen. I’ve got an idea. Let’s roll education back to the 18th Century when education was exclusively in the hands of religious institutions and only the nobility could afford an education. That would solve all of our problems

            1. Always interesting to see Liberalism on display.

              Avoid the issues, attack the messenger, and above all cling to what hasn’t worked.

              Your attempt at Reductio ad absurdum is boring

      3. Wow, in a Catholic school, if a kids does not behave you simply kick him out. Not to mention you provide NO Special Education services what so ever. You get to pick and choose your population, and you pay your teachers even worse than we are paid. I know because I taught at a catholic school. I got out as soon as I could.

        1. You avoid a key point. Catholic Schools graduate kids who can read, do math, have a sense of discipline, an understanding of the concept of merit and basic manners.

          SPECIAL EDUCATION DOES NOT BELONG IN EVERY SCHOOL.

          YOU BET AND I AGREE, UNRULY KIDS OUGHT TO BE KICKED OUT. ALLOWING THEM TO REMAIN DEPRIVES EVERYONE ELSE OF AN ATMOSPHERE CONDUCIVE TO LEARNING!!!!!!!!

          SO YOU QUIT. AND THAT PROVES WHAT? THE FACTS REMAIN THAT DAY IN AND DAY OUT CATHOLIC EDUCATION ACHIEVES ITS MISSION

  14. This is not just a local epidemic but a national crisis. my salary has been reduced 3 times in the past 4 years while our superintendent was offered a more than $200,000 bonus and many of us are now struggling to pay our basic bills, living expenses! Lord, help us all!

    1. I agree, administrators are way over paid and there are too many.

    2. I Am Grateful Avatar

      🙄😂😂😂💲💲💲💲💲
      Mo money for Denise please….

  15. Richard Spilman Avatar
    Richard Spilman

    I used to teach at Wichita State. I had to work at teaching them that gratitude was one of the hallmarks of morality in Jane Austen’s fiction. They found that strange. In composition classes sophisms seem more true to them than truth because they “work.” A respect for differing views is weakness. As a culture we treasure “realities” in which people get into fights over nothing. Journalists regularly ask not “What do you think?” but “What do you feel?” Drugs are a perfect fit for this culture because in a drug-induced stupor nothing matters but what you feel. Legislators don’t care about you because they don’t care about the kids you teach. The future is something that will happen when they are dead, so why bother thinking about it? This may be happening in a lot of other places, but it is happening more in America than anywhere else, and sometimes the moralists are the worst of the bunch. We are raising our grandkids; their paternal grandparents are raising another set of grandkids. We look at our doctors’ reports and our calendars and we know this can’t last long, and then what?

  16. Sherri Morris Avatar

    Mr Wedel
    What a wonderful and honest piece. This is the primary reason I do not support our money going to overseas causes and our philanthropists who insist on helping people in other countries first.

  17. Thank you for sharing.
    I hope it gets better.
    Teachers have influenced my life so much and I still think about them every day as I am in college.

  18. This was me in 2008. I had to quit–I couldn’t be a part of that system that was perpetuating harm on me, my daughter, my students, and my fellow teachers. And I was SO exhausted that I didn’t truly recover from that for two years after I stopped teaching–it was virtually as bad as a head injury or a major physical illness, living under THAT much stress, constantly, for five years. Not being paid enough was a factor as well–my own daughter was on reduced lunch–but the exhaustion was the worst thing.

  19. Thank you for writing this, sir. As a student, in what is sadly one of the better school districts in my state, I’ve seen many of the things you speak of. I’ve done what I can to help classmates and other students. Bringing an extra lunch because they can’t afford one, sharing study guides because they were too busy hiding from an abusive parent to fill theirs out, and just offering a listening ear and a shoulder to cry on. And I’ve seen teachers struggle to do all that and more *in addition to their actual, paid job.* I’ve seen bad teachers too, and teachers too burnt out to care anymore. But teachers like you are what keep the students going. You’re the only reason some of us survive long enough to graduate. You’re certainly the reason some of us graduate. Because as much as we may try to support each other, when so many of us are struggling – whether with school itself, or with things at home, or something else, or all of the above – that becomes increasingly hard to do. Teachers like you do your best to fill in gaps and build up support. You provide love, compassion, attention, and wisdom so many of us can’t get anywhere else. And when lawmakers pull stunts like this, it breaks my heart as much as it enrages me. Because we need you. Without teachers like you, even the good students, the ones with decent homes and caring families, fail to thrive and even fail to survive. We get trapped in cycles we feel are beyond our control. Because teachers like you weren’t there to show us that they’re not. So thank you for writing this, and I pray it gets the attention it truly deserves. Because you’re right. Something has to change and soon. Or we lose all hope, any chance, of having a real future.

  20. This letter is propaganda for the purpose of pushing the public to pass the one cent sales tax proposal. More money for more stealing

Leave a reply to Denise Jones Cancel reply