Open Letter to Oklahoma Voters and Lawmakers


I am a teacher. I teach English at the high school of an independent district within Oklahoma City. I love my job. I love your kids. I call them my kids. I keep blankets in my room for when they’re cold. I feed them peanut butter crackers, beef jerky, or Pop Tarts when Michelle Obama’s school breakfast or lunch isn’t enough to fill their bellies. I comfort them when they cry and I praise them when they do well and always I try to make them believe that they are somebody with unlimited potential no matter what they go home to when they leave me.

What do they go home to? Sometimes when they get sick at school they can’t go home because you and the person you’re currently shacking up with are too stoned to figure out it’s your phone ringing. Sometimes they go home to parents who don’t notice them, and those are often the lucky kids. Sometimes they go home to sleep on the neighbor’s back porch because your boyfriend kicked them out of the house and his dog is too mean to let them sleep on their own back porch. They go home to physical and verbal abuse. They go home looking for love and acceptance from the people who created them … and too often they don’t find it.

Many days your children bring the resentment they feel toward you to school with them and they act out against peers, property, or their teachers. When I call you I’m told, “When he’s at school he’s your problem.” Or you beat them, not for what they did, but because it embarrassed or inconvenienced you when I called.

Often, they stay at school with me for an hour and a half after the bell rings because they don’t want to go home to you. Reluctantly, they get on the two buses meant to take home students who stay for athletic practice, and they go away for a dark night in places I can’t imagine.

Over 90 percent of the kids in my high school are on the free or reduced lunch programs. The walk hand-in-hand with Poverty and its brother Violence. They find comfort in the arms of your lover, Addiction. They make babies before they are old enough to vote. Or drive. And they continue the cycle you put them in.

Sometimes I get through to a student and convince her that education is the way out of this spiral of poverty and despair. Then you slap them down for wanting to be better than you.

And you, the lawmakers of this state, you encourage it. I hold two college degrees and have been on my job for 10 years. I was our school’s Teacher of the Year in 2014. I teach kids to read the ballots that keep you in your elite position. I teach them to look behind your lies and rhetoric. I teach them to think for  themselves. The compensation of me and my colleagues ranks 49th in the nation, and is the lowest in our region. I currently earn about $18,000 per year less than I did in 2002, my last year as an office worker for an energy company that merged with another and eliminated my job. I feel like my life has purpose now, but, as I turn 50 this year and wonder how I’ll put my own high school-age kids through college, I have to consider giving up helping scores of kids per year so I can afford to give my own children what they need to find satisfaction in their lives.

And what do you do? You whittle away at education funding. You waste the taxpayers’ money so that our great state faces unbelievable shortfalls and massive budget cuts. You take home a salary that ranks 10th highest in the nation among state legislators and you are inept, uncaring, and an abomination to our democratic form of government.

Those kids who stay after school with me? After Spring Break 2016 they can’t do that. You see, our district can no longer afford to pay to run those late buses. Your kids wade through garbage in the halls because we had to release the custodial crew that cleaned at night. Oh sure, we could make the kids clean up after themselves, except our administrators live in fear of lawsuits, and making a kid pick up the lunch tray he threw on the floor has been considered forced child labor. There’s also the very real possibility that a belligerent kid will just take a swing at one of us — again — because he or she wasn’t taught respect for authority at home. Did I mention how we had to let go of our security officers because we could no longer afford them? We now share one single solitary Oklahoma County Sheriff’s deputy with our ninth grade center and our middle school and alternative school. That’s one deputy for about 1,300 students.

We can no longer afford rolls of colored paper or paint or tape to make signs to support and advertise our Student Council activities. This fall our football team won’t charge through a decorated banner as they take the field because we can’t afford to make the banner. There won’t be any new textbooks in the foreseeable future. Broken desks won’t be replaced. We’re about to ration copy paper and we’ve already had the desktop printers taken out of our rooms.

We live in fear that our colleagues will leave us, not just because they are our friends, but because the district wouldn’t replace them even if we could lure new teachers to our inner-city schools during the teacher shortage you have caused. We fear our classes doubling in size.

We fear becoming as ineffective as you are. Not because we can’t or won’t do our job, like you, but because you keep passing mandates to make us better while taking away all the resources we need just to maintain the status quo. We fear that our second jobs will prevent us from grading the papers or creating the lesson plans we already have to do from home. We fear our families will leave us because we don’t have time for them.

I am the chairman of my department. My teachers could easily take other jobs in the private sector where they would make more money, but so far they have chosen to remain teachers because they love working with kids. How long will they continue to put the needs of students over the needs of family? It’s something we’re all dealing with. How far will you push us? What will you do without us when we leave the classroom or leave the state? It’s happening. You know it’s happening, and yet you do nothing.

You, the representatives, senators, and governor of Oklahoma are creating a population of ignorant peasants fit only to work in the oil field and factories you bring to this state by promising those businesses won’t have to pay their fair share of taxes. You leave our kids in a cycle of poverty and abuse while your pet donor oil companies destroy the bedrock beneath us, shaking our homes to pieces while you deny your part in all of it.

Parents, I beg you to love your children the way we love your children. Vote for people who will help teachers educate and nurture the kids we share. We can’t do it alone anymore.

795 responses to “Open Letter to Oklahoma Voters and Lawmakers”

  1. If Donald Trump is elected President you can kiss public education goodbye. He, like Bill Gates, wants to put our children’s education in the hands of corporations, owning and operating charter schools.

    1. Charter schools are public schools that do a more efficient job of educating kids than traditional public schools mostly because parents that value education want their kids to go there. My kids are in a charter school where the wait list is 300 for a student population of about the same. My local public school has no wait list. My charter school has one principal and a governing board comprised of volunteer parents. My local public school has a principal and a bloated administrative staff that is paid >$250,000 each per year.

      Charter schools provide the competition that public schools have sorely lacked for 50 years.

      1. Yeah. That’s it. Problem solved, Dan. Why, oh, why didn’t you check in with us earlier? I could have avoided working with all those meaningless public school kids. Thanks so much for your wisdom and experience.

        1. By the way, was that you on my way to work this morning? You know, the guy in the red truck that zig-zagged in and out of the passing lanes and forced me off the road on I35? About 6:15am? You flipped me off and hollered that I should move over because my going over the speed limit by 5 wasn’t quite enough for you? I get your logic. You were only cutting me off for my own good. Thanks, man. Appreciate it.

      2. As a veteran charter school teacher, you are wrong. It is not the answer everywhere or for everyone, they are failing Michigan students. That isn’t to say there aren’t any good ones but overall, they are failing.
        As for competition, for the most part in Michigan, charters are built in the cities and the outskirts. Yeah, Federal funding! These charters are not a place of competitive education, they are a haven for students who have been kicked out of the public school (oh you brought a gun to school , come our way, yes this did happen). Your parents want to place you in a higher grade? Sure, we need bodies for count day.

        As for salary, start to research the managing company’s CEO, CAO or whatever the newest coolest set of abbreviations are; there you will find the real salaries.Examine whether or not the company is for profit or nonprofit, as well as, other companies under their umbrella. Google National Heritage Academies and Brooklyn, New York.

      3. Esther Flunkhousen Avatar
        Esther Flunkhousen

        Charter schools handpick their children and their educational focus. Public schools cannot. Public schools educate all children and deal with all the issues. Charter schools are like wolves in sheep clothing. They are elitist using public money.

        1. By law in most states, charter schools do not hand pick their students. Parents put them in a lottery and we select students completely blind. We have no information on them (no testing, school records, etc) and often don’t get any until halfway through their first school year. They have students with Individual Educational Plans that they don’t know about because the school district delays sending the information or the parent refuses to give it. Then the parent comes to school angry asking why we didn’t implement the plan. So no, they do not hand pick students. They simply come from a subset of parents who care about their kids.

        2. nonsense. show your source!

  2. Margaret Dinsmore Avatar
    Margaret Dinsmore

    Thank you for your courage and eloquence in communicating the Horrible state of affairs in Oklahoma. I share your frustration and pain but somehow continue to pray and to believe that somehow things will begin to change. Thank you.

  3. William Myricks Avatar
    William Myricks

    What is happening in Oklahoma is happening all over America. More and more teachers are becoming feed up with the conditions under which they are suppose to teach. I myself is a retired science teacher from Cleveland, Ohio. I managed to last for 25 years but the incoming teachers will have a very hard time lasting for 10 years. Why? Along with funding, the students are so different from years pass. Instead of a work ethic many students feel that the world owes them something and therefore do little or nothing to pass. Yet the teacher is expected to pass these students. The fact that students feel they can do anything they want lies with the courts, with the social service agencies, and with their parents. Plus I think school districts are afraid of the students and the parents. Maybe they are afraid of felonious lawsuits. If a teacher goes to count because of some altercation with a student, the teacher is always wrong and the student is always right. The students have been given all the rights but absolutely no responsibility. They hate all authority figures. Why not because when the push comes to stove nothing is going to happen to them. One has to wonder what will happen to those students who goes out into the world thinking they will have their way no matter what. Maybe parents could do a better job of discipline if the social service agencies did not interfere. I read a story about a football player who whipped his kid with a switch and the social service agency took the father to court. What message did this send to the child? If the kid was in harms way, I say of course call the social service agency but If it is not a matter of life or death let the parent handle the situation.

  4. Wow. Your words are touching but the examples are horrifying. I went to OU and have a special place for my heart. It is so sad to hear your legislators are failing you so blatantly.

  5. Wow. Your words are touching but the examples are horrifying. I went to OU and have a special place in my heart for your State. It is so sad to hear your legislators are failing you so blatantly.

  6. Tell the Truth !!!

    1. Brilliantly Said !!!

  7. Your words are so true. Thank you for your courage to speak the ugly, candid truth. I’m sorry that the children and teachers are suffering. I hope that the citizens of Oklahoma show compassion, take responsibility for their communities and choose legislators who will do right by children, teachers and families.

    As for the parents, I know that those who care are out there. They want the best for their children too. However, the disillusionment that you’re expressing now at the 10 year mark of your career is what these parents and families have been living for a lifetime and, as you indicated, generations. Remember, your students’ parents were likely yesterday’s impoverished kids (the cycle indeed has continued). Addiction has become an escape from the reality of hopelessness. Don’t alienate your parents. If possible, partner with them to help them lift their children out of poverty.

    You’re right, the burden is too immense for teachers alone to bear. A shift in the right direction will take collaboration across a number of institutions, community groups and people in addition to legislative change.

    Don’t give up. You are doing God’s work and making a difference.

  8. I realize I’m singing to the choir here. Most of us have responded with camaraderie to Steven Wedel’s blog.

    Does anyone think that The Industrial Revolution was without loss/change to the way people lived? We are deep within the throes of The Technological Revolution, driven by for-profit (as well as, global) entities.

    We are the Orks, people. We don’t want to hear it, but we are the worker bees.

    The middle class gave it away all the while smiling, gazing lovingly into their eyes, and trusting our new master.

    All that was true was turned on its’ head. Teachers: the bad guys? You didn’t even question that? Never doubted it. Just tuned in and tuned out and let the TV tell you what to think?

    You fed the emotional, starved the cerebral.

    This nation has changed/is changing—good, bad, and other. We (Oklahoma) have an under-educated constituency. The 2016 election will usher us into the next wave. This is how transition works. Dismantle, resist, dismantle, re-orientate, dismantle, accept, dismantle, rebuild.

    What do you value? Do you value instant gratification and feel good emoticons or do you value long term, sustained viability?

    You can face plant into your cell or look up every once in awhile. This ruse was pulled on your watch. You weren’t paying attention. You were too busy taking selfies and checking for likes.

  9. Wendel: I’m also an English Teacher. I reside in NC and we have the same problems under a Republican dominated government here. I think that the problem is not a regional one,but a relative one of this era.

    1. Gy No: Education in this country has been on the decline since schools were desegregated and picked up speed after the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Today’s students spend more time on test preparation than learning. A lot of today’s students cannot read the average newspaper, written on a 7th grade reading level, never written a letter or even addressed an envelope, filled out a check or job application. This is a national problem, caused by all political parties. but appears more prevalent in “Red” states, where tax cuts result in less revenue coming in so infrastructure, services, and education gets cut to support more police hiring, nepotism, cronyism and pet projects. I commend you for not relying on main stream media for you information. Please continue using reliable sources such as .edu, .gov as always, be wary of .org websites. A lot of them have skewed information, supplied by corporations.

  10. Shalane Clayton Avatar
    Shalane Clayton

    Thank you for a thoughtful, eloquent and honest assessment of the state of education. I am sad to hear that Oklahoma is in such a sad state. I believe it is time for a national overhaul of the education system. Privatization is not the answer. A national standard for teacher education, teacher base pay, core academic standards and a PERIODIC assessment of student learning along the lines of the PISA, as well as national funding for basic structures, curricula, and teacher pay. With national standards for pay, performance, and professionalism funded by a flat tax . . . education could bring back the promise of the American Dream.

    Hang in there. Please. You can’t do it alone, but if we all work together for change, WE can.

    1. All the so called education/standards will not fix the systemic issues.
      Schools are being used as a tool for radical social programs.
      The resources for education are being siphoned for services and activities that have nothing to do with education.
      A simple example is sports. Sports has zip to do with the ability to read, comprehend, perform simple math, but sports is viewed as glamorous, character building, etc.
      Let’s all face reality. Many sports figures are druggies, wife/girlfriend beaters, radicals, and outright thugs but nevertheless kids view them as heroes.
      Tke a look at where funds are spent when a school is built or remodeled. Are the millions for fancy sports facilities going to enhance learning? NO!
      How about the kids anyone can see are abused at HOME? Are schools going to stop this? NO! Do schools even report the abuse to the proper authorities? NO! Do the authorities take action to stop the abuse, hold the parents accountable? NO!
      Do authorities tolerate slums, drug sales on the corner, nightly shootings, etc. YES! Chicago, Baltimore, Detroit all come to mind.
      Schools are in trouble and as the kids precisely because of external factors beyond the schools ability to correct and in fact schools ought never have the ability to correct.
      Schools should teach, PERIOD!

  11. Hilde De Boeck Avatar
    Hilde De Boeck

    Having been a fulltime teacher for 28 years, I agree with the letter, although I am Belgian. I taught at a vocational training school with lots of migrant children, mainly Maroccans (often criminal : murderer, drugdealing, drugtraffick, shoplifting, burglary, weapon traffick, etc)) , Turks, Congolese, Rwandese among other nationalities. Yes, there were Belgians too. I wrote a similar letter to a friend ( dentist), telling him what our problems were, especially with the Maroccans. I think some of our buildings are derilict, but at least they are trying to improve the conditions and sometimes they even build new classrooms. The few children I have been able to ‘reach’ are still grateful for my unconditional love and attention and they themselves have tried to find me on facebook. When I stopped teaching, I was 51 and I was really fed up with the schoolsystem, not getting much response from the school principal. My husband offered me the opportunity to move to South Africa, where we are living now and enjoying the sun and life in general.

  12. What happened to the promises of 2008 Presidential election? Didn’t they all say they will improve education? Will someone please replay a video of those debates and campaign rallies?

  13. Thank you Wendel, for expressing what thousands of teachers are feeling across the country. However, I don’t think you went far enough. All those politicians and “reformers” who are trying to “improve” our education system, especially in inner-city schools, have 0 understanding of how students learn. These “reformers” are measuring what goes on in these schools only in terms of productivity and money. Each student for them is just another piece of raw material. Their theory is that if teachers will teach students “correctly” according to national standards (core curriculum), every student (raw material) should be able to become successful and demonstrate a substantial growth by scoring high on a standardized test. The other part of this theory is that if students’ scores are low, then it must be the fault of the teachers, who are “bad” teachers. I would like these “reformers” to attempt to teach a class in an inner city school for several days in order to understand that theories and standards by themselves do not produce good students. All these theories and standards completely ignore the human factor. Where is the calculation for the issues these students have to endure in their neighborhood and at home, as you described in your writing.? How do you measure the lack of physical, emotional and academic support, which has a greater impact on students’ ability to learn than the implementation of certain standards? Where are the measurements for violence, lack of food, dysfunctional families, and all the other factors that affect students ability to succeed? What they don’t measure is the special relationship teachers create with these students. Many of these teachers take the role of parents: they provide students with food, an open heart to listen to their students’ struggles and a lot of words of encouragement and advice. These special relationship are necessary before dealing with the academic success of students in general, but more particularly in inner city schools. Unfortunately, teachers do not get credit for this factor, and instead are evaluated based on standards that are almost impossible to implement in inner city schools. Unfortunately, all this, together with lack or negative administrative support, inadequate technology and supplies, reduction in teachers’ pay and benefits and the decline in teachers’ morale are having a destructive impact on our education system. It effects many dedicated teachers, who are eitehr let go for the wrong reasons or decide to quit their position or the teaching field altogether. However, the real victims in all these attempts to “reform” or “improve” the educational system are, of course , the students themselves.

  14. Dolores Williams Avatar
    Dolores Williams

    I am a retired kindergarten teacher (1999) and at that time things needed to be addressed, but as usual, no money for education. But for some reason, money was available to cover the expenses and raises of our congressmen. My son is a teacher at your Middle School, so I was aware of the situation at your school before your letter became public. What a shame that each member of Congress is not required to spend a day as a teacher; making plans, grading papers, doing outside duties, and other requirements, as well as teaching a class of many undisciplined and disruptive students. Maybe then they would find the money for teachers and perhaps include retired teachers, as well. Our 1% cost of living payment, ( which we don’t get every year) needs to be increased, but of course, there is no funding for us. Thank you for taking the time to write your informative letter. You really said it like it is, and that isn’t easy to do.

  15. For all the commenters, what are you doing about this? Are you investing in children like the author? Are you working to rid our state of the frauds who occupy the House and the Senate? Does your contempt of the Governor move you to do something beyond rhetoric? What the author is challenging us to do and be is to engage and do so at a level that will make a lasting difference.

    1. David Anderson Avatar
      David Anderson

      I am trying to teach for free

    2. David Anderson Avatar
      David Anderson

      I just wrote a long letter on this post…it never showed up

    3. M. J. Rudakewich Avatar
      M. J. Rudakewich

      I am a retired school librarian in Pennsylvania. I loved my job and had no intentions of retiring until I was at least 70, but my position and the high school position were merged because of funding cuts and I could not see how I could still handle my elementary class load (6 or 7 classes a day) and manage the high school, too. I now volunteer, along with other retired librarians, at a neighboring school district’s elementary school entering several thousand library books into the new computerized circulation system. It is slow and tedious and we can only come when the library is not in use for art or music or (GADS!) library, but we may finish next year.
      Because of the impasse with our Republican legislature and our Democratic governor , Pennsylvania has not had a budget since June 2015. State funding for school districts has not been released for the 2015-2016 school year, forcing cash strapped districts to borrow money. Some may shut their doors after Easter break. Last election we voted out our Republican governor after one term — unheard of in Pennsylvania where our governors always serve two terms. This coming election I hope voters will hold the state legislators accountable and vote them out of office as well. I will be helping at the local Democratic Party office to get out the vote.
      That’s what I am doing.

  16. On another note, the $19 million that could have been saved by consolidation of school districts in Oklahoma was defeated by those administrators (all school districts in Oklahoma are administratively top heavy) {and legistlators} who continue to be overpaid given the salaries of those they oversee. Would the last teacher to leave Oklahoma, please turn out the lights?

  17. I thank you for speaking out on Education but as a parent who is “in this cycle” of poverty, with a M.Ed. I found yourbcomment a little insulting. Our plight is legislated, our demise is legislated, our lack is legislated and education malpractice is legislated. We are in survival mode. We do not need “White saviors” flying in and giving our children false hope and false outlooks. This racist America is killing our children of color and you want to teach them or have them to act like and speak like they share white skin? No thanks! What you are doing will most definitely get them sprayed with bullets because they are not privy of their history. Whites came in and took our disciplining rights away to control our children, whites came in and robbed us of education empowerment, so dismiss me with that WE SHOULD LOVE OUR CHILDREN LIKE YOU DO, DO YOU REALLY? How are WHITES making lucrative salaries on the backs of poor ignorant Blacks? I GUESS BECAUSE YOU CARE SO MUCH!

    1. Wow. I haven’t had the displeasure of reading such a blatantly ignorant, loathsome, bigoted and racist rant in quite a while.

      The saddest thing of all? I wasn’t the least bit surprised that it came from a black woman.

      1. Totally agree! Wonder what discipline she speaks of? Beating? Depravation? Confinement in a closet?

        As for whites making $$$, has she bothered to look? Balcks are only 13% of the USA’s population. Today, Blacks receive a disproportion of the resources designed to create and foster opportunities.
        Blacks are permitted to have exclusive Black organizations and media. Blacks are permitted to have their exclusive Black History. Blacks are permitted to have Black only colleges. Blacks are permitted to have Black only Student Unions. Black sports figures constitute 80% of the NFL

        Stop your racism and excuse making. It’s boring.

    2. An understanding of world history would reveal a plethora of atrocities across race and ethnicity over time. My ancestors, the Irish, were about obliterated with the potato famine. Black America does not have exclusionary rights to a history of atrocities.

      Nothing grows without light. If you want a new day, dig a hole dip enough to bury your anger, cover it and walk away. Then find yourself some better dirt, plant a new seed, tend to it, make sure it has water to nourish it. Allow the sun in.

      You can’t hang on to the angry AND make a new day. It doesn’t work. It just doesn’t.

      You can’t SEE my history because I am Caucasian. Yet, my history existed. The troubles lasted long and cut deep and wide.

      The Irish sought out a new day. No one GAVE them a new day. They made one new day and then another new day and then another new day, until no one remembered how the Irish had been received in America. Until everyone is a little bit Irish on St. Patty’s Day.

      If I teach your child to read, am I a white savior? Or am I a teacher?

      We are all in survivor mode.

  18. What makes this guy better than every parent in America? You can’t base ones shortfalls on everyone in the country, if that was the case how come almost ALL the teachers I’ve known do not give a shit about any students. If I based my logic of thinking about one teachers short comings in every teacher there was I’d be in the same boat as this guy. I’m all for standing up when you need to but playing the blame game and patting yourself on the back isn’t gonna fix anything. Does money really play that big of a role in changing a kids life? NO we need to learn to make do with what we have it’s part of life it always has been and always will be a struggle it’s what makes us human. We are all products of our environments but that doesn’t determine the people we are in the future, that choice falls in the person ultimately.

  19. […] Source: Open Letter to Oklahoma Voters and Lawmakers […]

Leave a reply to Dolores Williams Cancel reply