Open Letter to Oklahoma Voters and Lawmakers


I am a teacher. I teach English at the high school of an independent district within Oklahoma City. I love my job. I love your kids. I call them my kids. I keep blankets in my room for when they’re cold. I feed them peanut butter crackers, beef jerky, or Pop Tarts when Michelle Obama’s school breakfast or lunch isn’t enough to fill their bellies. I comfort them when they cry and I praise them when they do well and always I try to make them believe that they are somebody with unlimited potential no matter what they go home to when they leave me.

What do they go home to? Sometimes when they get sick at school they can’t go home because you and the person you’re currently shacking up with are too stoned to figure out it’s your phone ringing. Sometimes they go home to parents who don’t notice them, and those are often the lucky kids. Sometimes they go home to sleep on the neighbor’s back porch because your boyfriend kicked them out of the house and his dog is too mean to let them sleep on their own back porch. They go home to physical and verbal abuse. They go home looking for love and acceptance from the people who created them … and too often they don’t find it.

Many days your children bring the resentment they feel toward you to school with them and they act out against peers, property, or their teachers. When I call you I’m told, “When he’s at school he’s your problem.” Or you beat them, not for what they did, but because it embarrassed or inconvenienced you when I called.

Often, they stay at school with me for an hour and a half after the bell rings because they don’t want to go home to you. Reluctantly, they get on the two buses meant to take home students who stay for athletic practice, and they go away for a dark night in places I can’t imagine.

Over 90 percent of the kids in my high school are on the free or reduced lunch programs. The walk hand-in-hand with Poverty and its brother Violence. They find comfort in the arms of your lover, Addiction. They make babies before they are old enough to vote. Or drive. And they continue the cycle you put them in.

Sometimes I get through to a student and convince her that education is the way out of this spiral of poverty and despair. Then you slap them down for wanting to be better than you.

And you, the lawmakers of this state, you encourage it. I hold two college degrees and have been on my job for 10 years. I was our school’s Teacher of the Year in 2014. I teach kids to read the ballots that keep you in your elite position. I teach them to look behind your lies and rhetoric. I teach them to think for  themselves. The compensation of me and my colleagues ranks 49th in the nation, and is the lowest in our region. I currently earn about $18,000 per year less than I did in 2002, my last year as an office worker for an energy company that merged with another and eliminated my job. I feel like my life has purpose now, but, as I turn 50 this year and wonder how I’ll put my own high school-age kids through college, I have to consider giving up helping scores of kids per year so I can afford to give my own children what they need to find satisfaction in their lives.

And what do you do? You whittle away at education funding. You waste the taxpayers’ money so that our great state faces unbelievable shortfalls and massive budget cuts. You take home a salary that ranks 10th highest in the nation among state legislators and you are inept, uncaring, and an abomination to our democratic form of government.

Those kids who stay after school with me? After Spring Break 2016 they can’t do that. You see, our district can no longer afford to pay to run those late buses. Your kids wade through garbage in the halls because we had to release the custodial crew that cleaned at night. Oh sure, we could make the kids clean up after themselves, except our administrators live in fear of lawsuits, and making a kid pick up the lunch tray he threw on the floor has been considered forced child labor. There’s also the very real possibility that a belligerent kid will just take a swing at one of us — again — because he or she wasn’t taught respect for authority at home. Did I mention how we had to let go of our security officers because we could no longer afford them? We now share one single solitary Oklahoma County Sheriff’s deputy with our ninth grade center and our middle school and alternative school. That’s one deputy for about 1,300 students.

We can no longer afford rolls of colored paper or paint or tape to make signs to support and advertise our Student Council activities. This fall our football team won’t charge through a decorated banner as they take the field because we can’t afford to make the banner. There won’t be any new textbooks in the foreseeable future. Broken desks won’t be replaced. We’re about to ration copy paper and we’ve already had the desktop printers taken out of our rooms.

We live in fear that our colleagues will leave us, not just because they are our friends, but because the district wouldn’t replace them even if we could lure new teachers to our inner-city schools during the teacher shortage you have caused. We fear our classes doubling in size.

We fear becoming as ineffective as you are. Not because we can’t or won’t do our job, like you, but because you keep passing mandates to make us better while taking away all the resources we need just to maintain the status quo. We fear that our second jobs will prevent us from grading the papers or creating the lesson plans we already have to do from home. We fear our families will leave us because we don’t have time for them.

I am the chairman of my department. My teachers could easily take other jobs in the private sector where they would make more money, but so far they have chosen to remain teachers because they love working with kids. How long will they continue to put the needs of students over the needs of family? It’s something we’re all dealing with. How far will you push us? What will you do without us when we leave the classroom or leave the state? It’s happening. You know it’s happening, and yet you do nothing.

You, the representatives, senators, and governor of Oklahoma are creating a population of ignorant peasants fit only to work in the oil field and factories you bring to this state by promising those businesses won’t have to pay their fair share of taxes. You leave our kids in a cycle of poverty and abuse while your pet donor oil companies destroy the bedrock beneath us, shaking our homes to pieces while you deny your part in all of it.

Parents, I beg you to love your children the way we love your children. Vote for people who will help teachers educate and nurture the kids we share. We can’t do it alone anymore.

795 responses to “Open Letter to Oklahoma Voters and Lawmakers”

  1. Reblogged this on You Are! and commented:
    I agree 100%! Our teachers need our help!!!

  2. As a teacher for more than 40 years (1965-2012) I know that what Steven says is so very true! Even if one teaches in a “wealthy school” a teacher has to deal with lawyers representing students who didn’t get an A, even though those students didn’t do the work. I truly care about the many students I have taught in Alabama, Georgia, and Texas. My son now is a teacher, and I did not encourage him to do so because he has a family of 5 to support. State legislators have no clue what goes on in the classrooms of their district; perhaps they need to sit in classes at various educational levels so that they will see what teachers need to TEACH.

  3. Invite those legislators to your schools, have them sit in your classes and see the REAL world in action. My sister teaches 3rd grade and I have helped in her class, it breaks my heart what they (teachers) have to put up with. Remember they are molding the minds of the next generation!
    How do we want our country remembered?

  4. I’ve been a substitute teacher in an urban setting in lower NY state for 9 years. What this teacher says about government handing out tax-exempt business deals, while cutting education funding is very true. But it’s also obvious. Less obvious is exactly the other area addressed here: Parents shirking all responsibility for even the most basic human needs: breakfast and clean clothes! If these parents can afford cell phones (even the homeless have cell phones!) then they can afford a box of store-brand cereal and a quart of milk. They can afford a bar of Ivory soap to wash out their kids’ clothing in a sink, if need be! And school supplies: They’re given out both free and literally for nickels and dimes at the beginning of the school year!
    But if no one is “watching the store”; if parents are too stoned, drunk, turning tricks in hallway or just too plain selfish and lazy to care.– and if no one is saying: “This is wrong!” …the kids don’t even get to take advantage of the freebees! I’ve dismissed Pre-Ks and shuddered at the thought of handing over 4-year-olds to some of the people that showed up to take them.
    How can anyone be expected to transfer any knowledge without a significant measure of order and respect? Respect is supposed to be taught at home. But now, even when it’s not….the teacher or school can barely take any action to instill it for fear of some kid of retribution! (I had a 2nd grader who kept jumping out of the chair, causing it to fall backwards, everyone to laugh and generate a general disturbance. I warned him repeatedly, and finally took the chair away, with the intention of having him stand by his desk for about 10 minutes. An aide came running over to tell me I’d better give him the chair back or I will be accused of cruelty!)
    Poverty is not a new phenomenon. This isn’t about race and not even money. It is about someone – preferably the person known as “mom” or “dad” – caring! Having some standards and dignity for themselves without waiting for “experts” to develop a “program” that will give it to them! It is better for a child to live in one room with someone who says: “Time to get up!”; “Is your homework done?”; takes them to the library occasionally and most importantly: is not afraid to use the word “NO!”, than to receive all the programs and expert-isms out there! Should the caring person manage to get the child some religious education…so much the better! (Too bad if that’s not PC! This issue is too important not to speak truth! Even the most problematic human being has a soul that needs to be nourished and feel like he/she is part of something greater than him/herself!) What’s needed is fewer “experts” and more genuine “parents”! Money alone can’t correct this.

    1. Stephen Yeates Avatar
      Stephen Yeates

      I personally do not think, it’s about parents who do not care, it’s much more. It’s about a society that places profit above all else. A society where capitalism rules, absolutely. Where, to go against that principle, leaves you open to cries of “you are a socialist”, as if caring for others or having the intelligence to understand that society needs an holistic and caring approach, renders you a lesser mortal. That we allow society to degenerate to the haves and have nots based on the criteria of ones ability to gain financial wealth while ignoring all other virtues is shameful. That we do not allow ourselves to contemplate the idea, that the very drug use that renders our children to be unloved, unwashed, un-fed or uneducated is symptomatic of a society that is fundamentally broken and need of nurture. If the capitilist were to just understand one thing, for me it would be; education is an investment, and that, if you must view the world in terms of return on investment, then the education of our future society is worth every penny. For those republicans out there that would troll me for my apparent democratic or liberal views, I am a caring capitalist, one that understands that we need business and social awareness.

      1. Basically, I agree with you. Yes, sad symptoms of society, BUT teachers are expected to fix all that under the present system, and they are not able to teach AND do all that fixing, too. Police came to your house and arrested Dad last night so you never got any sleep? Mom whacked out on whatever and not home evenings or nights? Sorry, but it’s a testing week, kiddo, and here’s yours. BTW, your teacher’s effectiveness as a teacher will be graded and judged on your scores because THAT’s the ROI that corporate reform micromanagement of education demands these days, and no matter what, it’s always all the teacher’s fault and always all about test scores. Any teacher can tell you that these tests are a basic waste of time at most grade levels. Nor do they benefit the student, or his teacher, or his instruction, or his parents. Over-testing and a focus on bogus test scores and only test scores. That’s one thing that’s been killing US public schools since NCLB. Teachers alone cannot fix poverty or its symptoms in a year, or 2, or 3, but big business, Wall Street, and big tech have been in charge of education for the past decade, and they want more! more! more! Immediate ROI’s.

  5. I find merit in the words of Mr. Wedel and that of each persons comment (witnesses). My personal witness is that of the so called poor (code word for minority especially (BLACK) who feign deprivation even while sporting high end attire credit lunch card in hand as white children wait in line in modest attire and sandals to pay cash for each meal. This affirmative action, poor me teacher mentality is embedded in our US Department of Education – public schools mentality. Return the responsibility and accountability for education of our children to each state. Stop experimenting with diversifying procedures and return to the basics of learning because experimentation with our children as mice is not working. I could not have written a better synopsis of our education plight – Mr. Wedel has in a minimum of words captured the prevalent conditions – but in his mentioning teacher pay nullifies his good work. Learning is not happening while more students each year graduate unable to read and or comprehend the simplest of subjects – and Mr. Wedel says teachers deserve higher pay. Most of the revelations of Mr. Wedel are not new but are well presented in a succinct manner sure to get much attention. unfortunately little action will follow – UNLESS – (I REPEAT) – We shut down the US Department of Public Education and return the education of our children to each individual state.

    1. It is the state of Ok that has defunded education and lowered pay. So how would shutting down the Dept of ed help ?
      You want qualified teachers you need to pay for them. As for experimenting on students , I don’t know what you mean , I guess common core? Our education system does need to advance to the 21 century, we do need common standards. I had to move several times as a child and to find not only are you the new kid but far behind the class in the new state isn’t helpful.
      I also grew up in poverty because women were and are paid significantly less than men, it’s demoralizing to be the poor kid that receives free lunch , it wasn’t a source of pride for anyone. I am frankly tired of the welfare queen BS. The nice designer cloths I did have were purchased by my Father who had a good paying UNION job. My Mother worked sometimes several jobs, there wasn’t much time left to help us do homework. I don’t blame her but people need to understand there are only 24 hours in a day.
      She wasn’t the parent this Teacher was talking about, but we were judged and ostracized just the same. As if poverty is contagious or we have no morals or manners. Teachers like this man are few and far between and are far more valuable than any overpaid legislator. I learned all about people like you when I was in third grade and I have deeper empathy because of it.

  6. Guy J. Cardarelli Avatar
    Guy J. Cardarelli

    Parents do have responsibility for the welfare of their children. However, moving from public schools to charter schools only emphaizes the problem. Many charter schools do not allow for parental imput.

  7. Guy J. Cardarelli Avatar
    Guy J. Cardarelli

    Unfortunately, the Obama administration contributes to the destruction of public education. This destruction has been further moved beyond repair by the confirmation of John King as secretary of education.

    1. Even many Dems now admit that O’Bama was no friend to public education. It’s fairly well-accepted in the education community. O’Bama made NCLB worse. Everything had to be a race, a competition, and in that you always have winners and losers. Business model applied to federal ed law and the federal DOE.

  8. Thank you for speaking out! We need more citizens like you!
    Sp. Ed Classroom Assistant in the California School System

  9. Anthony Grasso Avatar
    Anthony Grasso

    Dear Steven,

    As a retired teacher I, as well as many of my colleagues, know what you are talking about. The Florida lawmakers are cut from the same cloth and have no clue what we were up against. They are over paid and resented paying teachers a decent salaries commensurable to the great responsibility they have been given each day. They same could be said at the Federal level.

    When I started teaching in 1971 I had 48 student in a class. Later I had 37 and could not believe it when years later this number dropped to 30. I had to fend off putting more students into my class up until the last year (2012) of my profession.

    These legislators(foxes) are more interested in guarding the hen house for political and financial gain rather than investing wholeheartedly in the education of young America. I sincerely commend you, Steven, on taking this stand multifaceted issue.

    Sincerely,
    T Grasso – Sarasota Florida

  10. Bless you for wading into all this and making a difference. As a parent with kids in the public school system, I agree– teachers are forced to do more & more with less & less each year. The trouble is here too. Fewer books replaced every year, always more “technology”, never more teachers, ever-increasing class sizes, a school store to teach “retail skills”, rather than science fairs, robotics, math competitions and debate teams, We no longer have school librarians (budget cuts), we have “media secretaries” who can be paid on a lower scale. Our high school library closes as soon as school lets out, so no studying after school.

    The numbers of children in my son’s graduating class has dropped by almost a 100 since freshman year. Where did they all go??

    As a public librarian, we see those kids too– the ones afraid to go “home”, so they hang out and play on our public (filtered) computers from the time school ends to the the time we close. We speak to them with kindness, treat them with respect, and let them stay well past their “allowed” time, because we know at least here they’re warm and safe. And maybe, we can add to the examples of how adults can and should behave and treat them.

    As Charles Dickens wrote so long ago:

    “From the foldings of its robe, it brought two children;
    wretched, abject, frightful, hideous, miserable. They knelt
    down at its feet, and clung upon the outside of its garment.

    ‘Oh, Man. look here. Look, look, down here.’ exclaimed the Ghost.

    They were a boy and a girl. Yellow, meagre, ragged, scowling,
    wolfish; but prostrate, too, in their humility….Where angels might have sat
    enthroned, devils lurked, and glared out menacing. No
    change, no degradation, no perversion of humanity, in any
    grade, through all the mysteries of wonderful creation, has
    monsters half so horrible and dread.

    ‘They are Man’s,’ said the Spirit, looking down upon
    them. ‘And they cling to me, appealing from their fathers.
    This boy is Ignorance. This girl is Want. Beware them both,
    and all of their degree, but most of all beware this boy,
    for on his brow I see that written which is Doom, unless the
    writing be erased. Deny it.’ cried the Spirit, stretching out
    its hand towards the city. ‘Slander those who tell it ye.
    Admit it for your factious purposes, and make it worse.
    And abide the end.’

    Not much has changed.

    1. Thank you, Jean.

      Charles Dickens understood. I’m glad you do, too.

  11. “… when Michelle Obama’s school breakfast or lunch isn’t enough… ” You couldn’t wait barely a couple of sentences to blame Michelle Obama for inadequate breakfast/lunches in your school. You lost all credibility for whatever else you rant about with me and that is sad IF anything else you say was true. Please supply any ,,, ANY link to a credible source showing Michelle Obama in charge of cooking or fixing the meals in your school and more importantly, the budget for said meals and the allotment of each food item as to portions for hungry children not getting food at home. Of all the seemingly incredible hurdles you list, THIS is what you start with? Your agenda shows pitifully, as this is not even about the children you profess so modestly to care about. Oh, and “in my opinion” ,,,, of course.

    1. Back at ya, P.

      Of all the other possible points of discussion which arise from Mr. Wedel’s essay, you decided to latch on to this perceived slight of Mrs. Obama.

      Wow.

      “Your agenda shows pitifully.”

      1. annnnndddd you said nothing. Kiss your buddy for me.

        1. P., I don’t believe for one moment that you failed to understand my reply. No matter; your messages have been communicated quite clearly.

          Thank you for living down to all my expectations.

          1. Yes, you are correct, I understood your attempt at obfuscation and redirection implicitly and answered in kind. The author may respond with a link to validate his statement, or rephrase the sentence (it being his choice). The statement “I feed them peanut butter crackers, beef jerky, or Pop Tarts when Michelle Obama’s school breakfast or lunch isn’t enough to fill their bellies.” is complete and coherent that left nothing to “infer”. I place myself in the hands of the commenters that claim to be teachers for 20 and 30 and 40 years, if the statement the author made was clear to his intention or had a need for someone to bend over backwards to be “inferred” in a different light.
            Whatever you say on his behalf is white noise unless you provide said link and then we could proceed along any inferred attitude I may have.

    2. SO THE OBAMA CRITICISM IS SUFFICIENT TO EN TER INTO YOUR PATHETIC CLOAK OF DENIAL ?

      1. Apparently, me.

        Personally, I’m taking P.’s injudicious remarks as a lesson well learned. With any audience of sufficient size, there will be a few members predisposed to question one’s basic thesis. Some of these tend to superficially listen until they reach the first point of disagreement – at which time their minds cease to accept input.

        The fact I didn’t take Wedel’s off-hand comment as an insult toward Mrs. Obama makes it that much more telling.

  12. Remove all the money hungry paid lobbyists for big companies and wall street who ensure the little people and fledging companies (sole prop and start ups) get beaten down year after year.
    The more the money hungry paid lobbyists the more oil-skinned politicians.
    Remove life time (generations of) politicians. The little people who suffer the front lines represent their states and after X years return for others to represent their counties and states.
    Because more legislation means more lawyers everywhere with up teen number of lawsuits for anything and everything.
    ————————————————————————————————————————
    In the end the caregivers for children, teachers, medical providers, transporters…etc all suffer since they bear the yolk of complying with laws that are made to support groups above the line.

  13. Annalisa Hardy Avatar
    Annalisa Hardy

    If only you had left an unfounded and politically partisan comment out of this letter you would have been able to speak for so many more of your colleagues. 1/3 of the young people in this country are too obese to serve in the military. This is the first generation that will live a shorter life span than their parents and grandparents. An honest effort on the part of the federal government to Improve the quality of the food our children eat shouldn’t be slammed. The federal school lunch program is an optional, opt-in or out program. If schools would rather serve doughnuts than apples more power to them. Not a very good investment in out kids, though.

    1. You do realize that school lunch programs had guidelines long before Michelle O’Bama changed and added to them, right? Never have I seen any school serve donuts for either breakfast or lunch, and that’s years before O’Bama.

  14. You do realize they hate you, they hate the children, they hate everything that takes money away from the billionaires and their political Dogma? They don’t care about children. They don’t care about education. They don’t care because JEBUS is coming back to save everyone if only they create a real Hell on Earth and force the Rapture. Why should they care about you? Why give a damn about some dirty children who feed off the State Teat?

    Your “leadership” needs replacing with real leaders. And I don’t see that happening in a State that doesn’t care enough to change.

  15. Reblogged this on Evolving Teaching and commented:
    Given the current government’s gouging of public education funding, in one of the richest provinces in one of the richest countries in the world, there will be many more teachers here in BC writing letters like this soon enough.

  16. Angela Messenger Avatar
    Angela Messenger

    I read your peice about the state of our children’s lives and the states failure to change. I agree with every word and fact you report. I am a grandmother of four children now getting educated in Oklahoma City and I’m frightened for them. I’m frightened for all of the children here who are as you described robbed if quality education through no fault of the dedicated teachers like yourself, but because the Politicsl System in Oklahoma is disgusting and inept. I’m writing in support of you and your colleges and to ask the question “what can I do to help?”

    1. Angela, the best thing you can do is vote for candidates who support public education this November. All the Oklahoma House seats are up for grabs and about half the Senate. Vote in people who will support education. Thank you!

  17. […] Write your own and send it to me.  Let’s tell it like it is.  See the Open Letter to Oklahoma Voters and Lawmakers.  It tells a story that cannot be ignored.  If we want our schools to be better, our communities […]

  18. This is very true! I was so eager to return to teaching about raising my son for four years just to be saddened by what high stakes testing has done to education and all those who truly love learning and children. Standardized testing killed education and left everyone behind!

    You are not alone and I am glad you had the guts to speak out. I cry every time I think about leaving the kids I love so much and the profession I love so much, but like you I feel overwhelmed, stressed out and worried about my own family needs.

    Please God Help Us! Help Us restructure this failing system and return the funds, passion and all the great teachers who already left!

  19. This just became weird.

  20. You speak for all of us! It doesn’t matter what state or age group we are teaching! It doesn’t matter if our students are rich or poor! Everything you are saying is SO TRUE!

Leave a comment